Eric D. Williams took over the Seahawks beat and Seahawks Insider blog in December. Williams has covered the Seahawks, Sonics and high school sports for The News Tribune since joining the paper in 2006. Eric lives in Tacoma with his wife and two children.
Tacoma News Tribune columnist Dave Boling also contributes to the Seahawks Insider blog.
- All
- Answers to your questions (511)
- Audio Files (358)
- Awards and honors (79)
- Brock Huard Analysis (22)
- Coaching Decisions (38)
- Coaching Staff (77)
- Flashbacks (7)
- Former Players (78)
- Front office (40)
- Paul Allen (6)
- Game Coverage (1229)
- Injuries (537)
- Interviews (64)
- Media Issues (33)
- Mike Holmgren press conferences (87)
- Minicamps (116)
- Miscellaneous (238)
- National Seahawks Coverage (67)
- NFL Draft (265)
- 2006 Seahawks Draft (37)
- 2007 Seahawks Draft (72)
- Draft-pick Signings (18)
- Mock drafts (16)
- Rob Rang Analysis (43)
- Scouting combine (36)
- NFL Europe (7)
- NFL free agency (363)
- Cuts and waivers (73)
- Character Issues (23)
- Restricted free agents (RFAs) (15)
- Street free agents (71)
- Tryouts (40)
- Unrestricted free agents (UFAs) (99)
- Cuts and waivers (73)
- NFL Meetings (39)
- Notes from practice (189)
- Off the field (137)
- Charitable endeavors (32)
- Legal system (61)
- Offbeat Stuff (51)
- Officiating (71)
- Opponents (152)
- Playoff picture (20)
- Predictions (41)
- Quotes (182)
- Matt Hasselbeck (18)
- Mike Holmgren (32)
- Shaun Alexander (13)
- Radio Shows (41)
- Roster Analysis (58)
- Schedules and calendars (40)
- Seahawks Insider (301)
- Blog News (282)
- Programming Note (223)
- Stadium/facilities (13)
- Stats, etc. (124)
- Excel Downloads (106)
- Draft-related files (9)
- Seahawks Roster (78)
- Statistics (97)
- Excel Downloads (106)
- Trades and potential trades (71)
- Training Camp (182)
- 2006 Training Camp (137)
- 2007 Training Camp (141)
- Video (8)
- Xs and Os (39)
| Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| << < | > >> | |||||
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |||
| 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 |
| 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 |
| 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 |
| 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 | |
- July 2009 (1)
- June 2009 (29)
- May 2009 (32)
- April 2009 (89)
- March 2009 (56)
- February 2009 (63)
- January 2009 (51)
- December 2008 (151)
- November 2008 (191)
- October 2008 (203)
- September 2008 (164)
- August 2008 (175)
- More...
For the first time since he tore his ACL, we spoke with Seahawks wide receiver Deion Branch, who clarified a few things regarding his knee and his comeback.
First, and perhaps most important, he had the surgery to repair the torn ACL on Feb. 7, which means that Sunday is the 7-month anniversary of his surgery.
He said there are three different ways to do the surgery. He chose the one that gives the knee more stability but takes a little while longer to heal. He could have had a cadaver's ligament placed in his knee, but Dr. James Andrews, who did the surgery, said he wouldn't do that surgery for him, he would have to go elsewhere. Instead, he chose to have a piece of his own patella tendon shaved off and made into his ACL.
This is where it gets a little hazy. He said you hear different things, 6-9 months from some doctors for recovery, 9-12 from others. I said, "Deion, every doctor I speak with said a minimum of 9 months recovery. Given the nature of the injury and your career is at stake, why would you try to come back early and risk the possibility of your career ending?" In the end, he never directly answered the question. "Who knows?" he said. "If it is eight months, like Dr. Andrews said, 'Deion, I can't tell you when you will be ready. You will know. I can tell you when your knee is locked down, yeah, but I can't tell you when you are ready to play football. That will be you.'"
Branch was asked if he would be able to play on Sunday. He said he will play when Coach tells him he can play. So, on the one hand, Holmgren is telling us that Branch will play when Branch tells him he is ready. And on the other, Branch is telling us he will play when Holmgren says he is ready.
My personal opinion is that, when you take everything into account -- the type of surgery, the timing of the surgery, the position he plays, and the waffling -- he is not close to being ready. Seven months is way too soon for this type of injury. And if I am either him or the team, I wouldn't risk his long-term health for a few games now. That's just me, they may have something else in mind.
As for the injury, he said he suffered it while running a route in that Green Bay game that he has run 1,000 times. He said it has nothing to do with the snow or the cold or the field or anything. He made a cut and he felt his leg go. He said he didn't know immediately -- his kneecap had slid to the side and he couldn't slide it back. He says now he thinks it was his muscles around the knee protecting his knee. But he said when he got to the sideline, the doctor was asking him if his knee was sliding back and forth when he walked. When he realized his knee wasn't sliding, that's when he knew what the injury was.
Having said all that, he was sure to point out that none of this was the hardest thing he has had to do in his life. His son was born with spinal meningitis, and to this day he can't walk. He says he wakes up to that every day and appreciates what he has. This does not come close.
Speaking of which, he is having a bowling tournament to raise money for spinal meningitis. Here are the details in a press release written by his foundation:
KIRKLAND – Seattle Seahawks Wide Receiver Deion Branch and his Deion Branch Charitable Foundation will present a Tuesday evening filled with fun, laughs, celebrity bowling on Tuesday, September 9 to benefit Meningitis Research. The Deion Branch’s “Charitabowl ” will begin at 6p.m. on September 9 at Lucky Strike located in Bellevue’s Lincoln Square Mall.
Team sponsorship in the tournament is $2,500 for a four-person team, and includes dinner, parking, a “Charitabowl” limited-edition bowling shirt and a team photo with Deion Branch. Individual tickets are available at a cost of $350. The “Charitabowl” will help raise funds and draw attention to meningitis research.
“My family and I wanted to help raise awareness and money for a cause that is near and dear to our hearts” said Branch, who established his foundation in 2002 after his son, Deiondre, was diagnosed with Meningitis. “It’s a chance for fans to come out, meet my Hawks teammates and raise money for Meningitis Research.”
The Deion Branch Charitable Foundation is currently accepting team sponsorships for the September 9th “Charitabowl” event up until 6 p.m. on Friday, September 5. Tickets and table reservations for the fund-raising event can be arranged by calling Matthew Wade, executive director of the Deion Branch Charitable Foundation, at (206) 227-9387 or logging onto www.deionbranch83.com.
COMMENTS:
First, this sheds a whole lotta light into why so many athletes go to Dr Andrews first (who is the hands-down best around) but then go out and have surgery with other docs. It's because Andrews won't build bionic men. Classy.
Second, Branch is on his last legs here on this team and he knows it. (No pun intended.) But given his injury history, I'm sure the team is ready to be done with him, one way or another. So therefore, there's pressure on both sides to get out there and play.
Chuck: Your probably right, but... Branch is certainly on the 53 man roster, but I think he hasn't been practicing with the team so much as just running around near the team, and because he hasn't passed a physical he could still be placed on PUP. Tell me how I'm wrong.
Branch hadn't been practicing with the team, but did today, and also was already added to the 53 man roster, so any use of the PUP is now impossible for him. It's IR or on the 53 man, that's it, unless you release the man, which we aren't about to do.
Branch isn't on his last legs here either. He has performed when he's been healthy, getting much better with Hass over the last year. However, given his injury concerns, the team may ask for a renegotiation after this season if the injury keeps him out of a significant number of games, or he gets some new injury along the way. He's valuable when healthy, just not worth as much if he isn't durable enough to play more consistently.
FNG from Puyallup, Wash., asks: Sando, The Seahawks plan to test [Deion] Branch's knee this week. If it were to not respond well, is he still eligible to be put on PUP as long as he has not passed a physical? If so, would that also be the case after week 1 when [Rocky] Bernard and [Jordan Babineaux] return?
Mike Sando: Rules prohibit teams from placing players on the reserve/physically unable to perform list after the mandatory cutdown to 53 players. The Seahawks had until Saturday to make that decision. They did not place Branch on the PUP list. That means Branch counts against the 53-man limit unless the team places him on injured reserve, which is season ending.
I don't see how he may be ready to play? Work out yes - play no. I can just see this turning into a recurring injury nightmare!
If he doesn't play by week 7, this will clearly be a bad decision that I think should have been avoided.
Besides- how would they feel if they pup'd him and he was ready to play prior?
As far as him "being on his last legs" I can only assume this is the typical fan reaction to high paid players that don't get the MVP in their first year.
If you watch Deion's play closely, he is a tremendous athelete and quite a remarkable football player. In 2006, at Kansas City Seneca Wallace threw an interception on a pass to Deion. Branch had the mental sharpness and physical ability to sprint up behind the player and strip the ball back. That was an incredible play and (in my opinion) proof that he was worth every cent he was paid - just in potential alone.
Inactives:
Coutu (Mare is our kicker)
Engram (injured)
Branch (injured)
Wrotto (Womack more important due to Lock's status)
Putzier (only need 2 TE's)
Atkins (could be Babin, but Babin practicing on ST's)
Frye (3rd QB)
Schmitt (I think, unless he's vital to ST's)
Babin is active because I don't think both DE's sit, and he's been practicing ST's this preseason.
Vallos is active due to Spencer's situation.
Womack is active due to Lock's situation and his ability to play everywhere on the line, except C.
Kent/Payne active due to injuries to Engram/Branch.
Forsett active to return kicks/punts with Burleson starting at WR.
Biggest question: T.J. Duckett. With Forsett active to return kicks Holmy might keep Putzier or Wrotto active and let Forsett fill in as the 3rd RB for now.
~Just my take
Branch: not ready yet
Engram: not even practicing yet
Locklear: Holmgren said he wouldn't be ready
Forsett: don't need 6 backs and been trying others at PR
Atkins: a little dinged up, Babin outplayed him anyway
Coutu: Mare won the job
Hawthorne: DD can backup Lofa and play outside
Frye: 3rd QB
And, can we please have a 4-week IR begining in week 7, after the PUP runs out? Again, all it will do is help teams keep a few guys here and there.
If they go to a 17 or 18 week schedule without these changes, it's gonna suck bigtime.
The 8 player inactive rule is to help out teams that have injuries while keeping a relatively equal playing field.
The rule was put into place so you can avoid situations where one team has 5 or 6 injured players and the other team is fully healthy. In this case you'd have one team only suiting up 47 or 48 players while the other team has 53.
It allows a team to carry injured players for a few weeks since all the injured players will take one of the inactive spots.
If it weren't for this rule any time a team had a player that was out for say 3 or 4 weeks (ala Branch and Engram) the team would have to IR them for the whole season and bring someone else in.
Hugh Millen on KJR today: "What is Deion Branch? His best game here was his first game against the Rams. Behind the scenes, (Belichek) will tell you there's a reason he let Branch go. He's a 5'8" guy, who's never lived up to potential. He's a hard worker, but what is he really? What do we expect of him?"
Branch is a bust, and people here have been saying it from nearly the time he's been here. He's fragile and fragile players don't last around here anymore. See also: Anthony Simmons, Wistrom, Hackett, etc.
Coming from someone with the nick "firejimmoradotcom" doesn't lend a lot of credibility to an argument.
Never lived up to potential? His stats and accolades speak for themselves/ Granted, that was before he came to Seattle.
Belicheck did not work the trade for those reasons, that is just the opinion of a single radio personality that is just parroting the same fan reaction that was just displayed.
Belechik is notorious for letting players go when they start asking for money, they turn their player rosters over pretty regularly outside of their key players. Those key players have a supporting cast. Receivers are nothing more than a supporting cast to Brady. Yes, even Moss.
I've said it before and I'll say it again. Branch should be on IR and should have been placed on IR weeks ago. Yes, he is far away from being ready to play, and with a 1st round draft pick given away for him and the money they've got tied up in him, it is mega-stupid to play him at all this season. To say "Gee a quarterback is back at such and such a date so why shouldn't a WR be" is foolish. When quarterbacks starting running routes and making cuts like receivers do, come back with that dumb argument.
MFA is proud to announce the new C.I.S.S. Container Identification Scratch System
When we participate in sporting events or mingle at social gatherings it is possible to lose track of our water bottles and/or beverage cans, especially those served in containers that are very similar or identical to a container from which you are drinking. This carries the risk of transmitting an illness, such as meningitis or the common cold or flu. The Container Identification Scratch System, or C.I.S.S., is a fun way to make sure you always know your drink from others. Use it at sporting events or at a family gatherings and reduce the waste from forgotten drinks. Simply scratch your number from the C.I.S.S. label and identify your drink. For more information please contact Bob Gold at Ciss.bob@gmail.com and www.musa.org
Thank you,
Ms. Jamie Callahan, General Manager
Meningitis Foundation of America
212 W 10th Street, Suite B-330
Indianapolis, IN 46202
(800) 668-1129
www.musa.org
Comments are not allowed from anonymous visitors. Please login or register to comment.

